Williamsburg · Wine bar / New American · $$$

When do The Four Horsemen reservations open?

ToughPublicly reportedResy

The Four Horsemen is a Wine bar / New American room in Williamsburg. Tables are booked on Resy. 30 days out at 7:00 AM ET.

Reservations open

30 days out at 7:00 AM ET

This is reported publicly and hasn't been confirmed by the restaurant. Confirm on the booking page before you set an alarm.

The secrets

Insider tips

The online book opens 30 days out at 7am and goes quickly. Walk-ins are a real plan: arrive around the 5:30pm opening and there is a decent chance of a table. If there is a wait, Nightmoves, the bar next door, is where you stand.
single report The Infatuation October 5, 2026
Seats are set aside for walk-ins. On weekends, arriving 45 minutes to an hour early has put people first in line, and staff start taking names roughly 45 minutes before doors.
multiple diners report Reddit June 8, 2026 · Reddit July 26, 2026
The low-stress version: put your name down around opening or 6:30, have a drink nearby, and expect a call in about 45 minutes. Solo diners arriving at open report being seated almost right away.
multiple diners report Reddit November 10, 2025
Lunch, where offered, is the easier walk-in; line up before open and expect about 30 minutes, since the team paces seating to protect the kitchen. Notify tends to surface late tables around 10:30 PM.
multiple diners report Reddit November 10, 2025 · Reddit July 26, 2026
The waitlist opens at 4:45 PM for the 5:30 dinner open, and the bar, one of the best seats in the house, is held for walk-ins. Lunch is the quieter alternative.
confirmed by restaurant Resy September 10, 2026

Last checked October 17, 2026. Paraphrased from public sources. Policies change, so confirm with the restaurant.

How hard, and why

Tough · 3/5

Editorial estimate. On the researched watch list, outside the very top of the city ranking. Evidence on sellout speed is limited, so this stays short of “very tough.”

An editorial estimate, not a feed from Resy or the restaurant, and not a guarantee. City ranking · How drops work

Book on Resy ↗

The details

Booking platform: Resy
Notify / waitlist: Resy Notify
Walk-ins: Yes; waitlist starts 4:45pm
Official site: fourhorsemenbk.com/
Last verified: 2026-10-17

Plan the night

Ask the concierge for a full evening built around The Four Horsemen, with a backup if the drop goes fast.

Plan with the concierge

Sources: primary · secondary. Info as researched Oct 2026.

Questions

When do The Four Horsemen reservations open?

30 days out at 7:00 AM ET. Source status: Publicly reported. Confirm on the booking page before the drop.

How do you book The Four Horsemen?

The Four Horsemen books via Resy. Waitlist/notify: Resy Notify.

Does The Four Horsemen take walk-ins?

Yes; waitlist starts 4:45pm.

How do people get a table at The Four Horsemen?

The online book opens 30 days out at 7am and goes quickly. Walk-ins are a real plan: arrive around the 5:30pm opening and there is a decent chance of a table. If there is a wait, Nightmoves, the bar next door, is where you stand. Seats are set aside for walk-ins. On weekends, arriving 45 minutes to an hour early has put people first in line, and staff start taking names roughly 45 minutes before doors. The low-stress version: put your name down around opening or 6:30, have a drink nearby, and expect a call in about 45 minutes. Solo diners arriving at open report being seated almost right away. Lunch, where offered, is the easier walk-in; line up before open and expect about 30 minutes, since the team paces seating to protect the kitchen. Notify tends to surface late tables around 10:30 PM. The waitlist opens at 4:45 PM for the 5:30 dinner open, and the bar, one of the best seats in the house, is held for walk-ins. Lunch is the quieter alternative.

Does Midnight Table sell reservations?

No. We send alerts and help you plan and book. Every reservation is made in your own name on the restaurant's own platform, and we never resell tables.