New York City · Italian
Best Italian Restaurants in NYC: How to Get a Reservation
10 restaurants in New York City are listed under Italian in this directory, ordered by Midnight Table's own difficulty estimate. That score is not official Resy or OpenTable data.
Ordered by Midnight Table's own difficulty estimate. The cuisine column is the label on file, including when several labels share this page.
| Restaurant | Difficulty | Neighborhood | Cuisine on file | When bookings open |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I Cavallini | Very tough 4/5 | Williamsburg | Italian | 14 days out at 8:00 AM ET |
| Lilia | Tough 3/5 | Williamsburg | Italian | Phone line opens 30 days out at 10:00 AM ET; remaining tables go online at midnight |
| Misi | Tough 3/5 | Williamsburg | Italian | 28 days out at 10:00 AM ET |
| Borgo | Tough 3/5 | Midtown | Italian | 21 days in advance at 10:00 AM. |
| Al Di La | Plan ahead 2/5 | Park Slope | Italian | Not published |
| Bamonte’s | Plan ahead 2/5 | Williamsburg | Italian | Not published |
| Cafe Carmellini | Plan ahead 2/5 | Midtown | Italian | Not published |
| Cafe Spaghetti | Plan ahead 2/5 | Columbia St | Italian | Not published |
| Casa D’Angelo | Plan ahead 2/5 | Little Italy | Italian | Not published |
| Locanda Verde | Plan ahead 2/5 | Tribeca | Italian Restaurant | Not published |
Other cuisines in NYC
All NYC cuisines · Hardest reservations in New York City · NYC release times
The newsletter
The Guestlist
Every Thursday: what's dropping next week, new rooms worth chasing, and the walk-in tricks the regulars use. Free.